By Dom Spencer - February 20th, 2024 Posted in Mortgage Guides No comments


When it comes to your mortgage options, a common dilemma is whether to opt for a 2-year fixed or 5-year fixed rate deal.

Understanding the differences between these two choices and deciding which aligns better with your financial circumstances is essential to making a good decision.

With that in mind, let’s dive into the differences to help you navigate this important choice.

What’s the difference between 2 and 5-year fixed rate mortgages?

As the names suggest, the fundamental difference lies in the duration for which the interest rate remains fixed. A 2-year fixed rate mortgage locks in an interest rate for two years, while 5-year fixed rate mortgage spans five years.

Why are the interest rates on 2 and 5-year deals different?

The interest rates on these mortgages can differ due to various factors, including prevailing market conditions, lender policies and economic forecasts. Typically, longer-term fixed-rate mortgages may have slightly higher interest rates compared to shorter-term options due to the increased certainty and stability they offer.

Aren’t 5-year fixed rates currently cheaper than 2?

Yes, but this is a recent development. Prior to the latter part of 2022, this wasn’t the norm.

As interest rates climbed in 2022 and 2023, 2-year fixed deals became more expensive. By the end of 2022, the interest rates for 2-year deals surpassed those of 5-year ones.

This change has driven by speculation that the Bank of England will decrease the base rate in the near future, meaning lenders’ pricing strategies have been set to entice borrows into longer-term mortgage deals.

Advantages of a 2-year fixed mortgage:

Flexibility: With a shorter fixed term, borrowers have the flexibility to reassess their financial situation sooner and potentially take advantage of better rates or change their mortgage strategy as needed.

Lower initial rates: Generally, 2-year fixed rate mortgages tend to have lower initial interest rates compared to longer-term options, which can be advantageous for those seeking immediate affordability.

Disadvantages of a 2-year fixed rate mortgage:

Renewal risk: After the initial term, borrowers may face the risk of their mortgage reverting to a higher variable rate or needing to remortgage, which could lead to uncertainty regarding future payments.

Potential fees: Refinancing or switching mortgages can incur fees and administrative costs, which borrowers need to consider when opting for shorter-term fixed rate deals.

Advantages of a 5-year fixed rate mortgage:

Rate stability: Locking in a fixed rate for five years provides stability and shields borrowers from potential interest rate hikes during that period.

Long-term planning: For those looking for long-term financial stability or who prefer to avoid the hassle of frequent remortgaging, a 5-year fixed rate mortgage offers the advantage of extended security and planning.

Disadvantages of a 5-year fixed rate mortgage:

Higher initial rates: 5-year fixed rate mortgages often come with slightly higher initial interest rates compared to shorter-term options, potentially impacting short-term affordability.

Limited flexibility: Committing to a longer fixed term means sacrificing some flexibility, as borrowers may be locked into their mortgage terms even if better options become available during the fixed period.

Is it better to get a 2 or 5-year fixed rate mortgage right now?

The answer depends on individual circumstances, financial goals and risk tolerance. Those seeking short-term affordability and flexibility may find a 2-year fixed rate mortgage more suitable, while those prioritising stability and long-term planning may lean towards a 5-year fixed rate mortgage.

Ultimately, making an informed decision requires careful consideration of personal finances, future plans and prevailing market conditions.

Consulting with a qualified mortgage broker can provide invaluable insights and assistance in navigating the complexities of mortgage options.

For personalised guidance and access to a comprehensive range of mortgage options, consider reaching out to us, our qualified whole-of-market brokers stand ready to assist you in making the right choice for your financial future.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *